Aikman: HOF???

[uscmd]

Sorry about the spacing..........it was in line when I entered it, got jumbled from my screen to post

 

[uscmd]

Testerverde will be a better test.....top 6 in 3 categories 8th in the 4th. But championships? lol.......maybe he did....who knows

 

[HinesWard86]

STOP WITH VINNY TESTAVERDE. I will boycott football if Testaverde goes into the Hall, he has ALWAYS been a bad QB. Just stop now.

 

[uscmd]

i agree......but for those who talk stats............hes right there.

Hes the argument for anyone citing stats as a hall pass

 

[docmercer--banned]

Its all where ya end up playing ....

think Steve Young becomes the qb he became if he remained in Tampa Bay? Would Favre end up w/his career achievements if he remained a Falcon??

The argument of winning SBs goes out the window as one of the top rbs in the 80s had 3 SB rings and cant get in: Roger Craig of the 49ers

Aikman is in the HOF ... and a qb who will never be mentioned when folks draw up the list of the ten greatest qbs of all time

 

[Fishhead]

Not a HUGE Aikmen fan, but he gets my vote on the first ballot for the HOF.

 

[WVU]

WOW fish, I didn't even know you get to vote. My ballot must have got lost in the mail

 

[roach23]

I hate the cowboys, but aikman was in a different class than randall. Randall wasn't a winner, he just put up good stats on ok teams. Aikman was the definition of a winner. He had a good enough team around him so he was up 20 points in the fourth quarter and never had to put up big numbers in the 4th quarter to pad his career stats.

Anyone that ever watched football during that era knows who was better. It wasnt even close. Aikman also had emmit smith who hogged many of the TDs and action. Cunningham didnt have to share the ball with a HOF RB.

Your argument is that Aikman is better because he HAD to play with Emmitt??

Randall never had any weapons on offense. If you seriously think Fred Barnett, Calvin Williams, Keith Byars and an old Herschel Walker can compare to Irvin, Harper, Emmitt, Novacheck, Moose you're crazy.

Add to that Randall never, NEVER, had an offensive line in Philly. He didn't even have an offenive coordinator. Rich fuckign Kotite was calling plays for him.

And what happended when Randall went to Minny and he had Robert Smith, Chirs Carter and Moss??? They went to the NFC Championship and would've won if that ***** kicker didn't miss a FG to win the game. Not to mention Randall won league MVP.

Don't forget Randall had the longest punt in NFL history for a few years as well, and i think now is #4 all time.

 

[CAPNCRUNCH]

Your argument is that Aikman is better because he HAD to play with Emmitt??

Randall never had any weapons on offense. If you seriously think Fred Barnett, Calvin Williams, Keith Byars and an old Herschel Walker can compare to Irvin, Harper, Emmitt, Novacheck, Moose you're crazy.

Add to that Randall never, NEVER, had an offensive line in Philly. He didn't even have an offenive coordinator. Rich fuckign Kotite was calling plays for him.

And what happended when Randall went to Minny and he had Robert Smith, Chirs Carter and Moss??? They went to the NFC Championship and would've won if that ***** kicker didn't miss a FG to win the game. Not to mention Randall won league MVP.

Don't forget Randall had the longest punt in NFL history for a few years as well, and i think now is #4 all time.

Randall was much better than Michael Vick! And he makes how much?

 

[5teamparlay]

Happy 52nd Troy

Troy Kenneth Aikman (born November 21, 1966) is a former American football quarterback who played for the Dallas Cowboys in the National Football League (NFL). The number one overall draft pick in 1989, Aikman played twelve consecutive seasons as quarterbackwith the Cowboys. During his career he was a six-time Pro Bowl selection, led the team to three Super Bowl victories, and was the MVP of Super Bowl XXVII. Aikman was elected to the Pro Football Hall of Fame in 2006 and to the College Football Hall of Fame on December 9, 2008 in New York City.[SUP][2][/SUP]