I think you have it nailed there SportSavant. It really is a matter of individual goals. Hey...some guys are looking for "action" and would be bored silly making $20 bets with a dime in their accounts. The problem I have with the way this thread started out is that we have a guy spewing "mortal locks" all over the place, advising people to hit plays hard....and then, after a bad day, getting on a soapbox and attacking other people's money management strategies. Sorry....but calling things "mortal locks" and throwing around words like "guarantee" and then in the next breath bashing anybody who advises playing more than 2% of BR on any play.....well that just sounds a tad inconsistent to me. Call me crazy.
Now I do absolutely agree that if you have an edge....and I daresay a lot of the cappers here (Braveheart certainly included) do have an edge)....meaning you are hitting over 53%, then you do want to spread your action over as many plays as possible so that a bad streak doesn't torpedo you.
From my own perspective, the ONLY time I feel I have an edge is when playing NBA totals...AFTER the third week of the season. So there is a decent, but nevertheless limited, amount of time to let this work for me. That is why I say $4 per unit on a $1,000 bankroll. At that level I feel you are giving yourself a shot to make some decent money, while SOMEWHAT protecting yourself against a bad streak.
But it comes down to this.....some people here have regular incomes and are doing this recreationally. In these cases I don't think the same rules that "professional gamblers" use apply. Sure...going an average of 4% per play with the occasional 8% is very risky.....and absolutely can lead to a zero bankroll. But a recreational player can handle that kind of risk, whereas a professional gambler....who is basically screwed in real life if his bankroll is gone.....cannot take that risk.
This has been a good topic in spite of all the "quips." Braveheart....I have a ton of respect for you as a capper, but you did kinda call me out.