I am joining this thread a bit late but I have to try to understand Gyno's *original* intent:
At first, thinking that ARI can get by ATL but then losing on the East Coast (against either CAR or NYG as originally possible)...
betting $30 to win $720 at +2400 for ARI to go to Super Bowl, essentially (in Gyno's eyes, he did think that was *NOT* going to happen)
He figured right about ARI beating ATL as the first step. He then bet on CAR ML because he saw that even *if* somehow, by a miracle, CAR does lose, he still can get a "hedged" profit at the NFC Championship week by betting on the other team, whoever it would be.
However, I understand that Gyno's mistake was not factoring into TWO consecutive hedging requirements on a favorite ML (CAR -410 being the first but not the only favorite) for him to realize the +2400 original bet to be cashed. *IF* NYG defeats PHI on Sunday, then we are talking about NYG being -410 or more with ARI visiting NYG.
+2400; risk $30 to win $720 for ARI to win NFC Championship
-410; risked $328 to win $80 on CAR (Gyno's "ideal" plan was to win $50 and tie this up right away)
-410; to risk $328 to win $80 on NYG (NYG won't be that low of -410, though)
If ARI still beats NYG at Meadowlands, then the $720 profit has been eaten by the -$328 losses twice by CAR and NYG failing to win. That'd be a mere $64 profit on ARI; but if NYG wins, Gyno would get a $50 profit over his ORIGINAL $30 bet on ARI to win NFC. This is what Gyno was trying to do but then he forgot about the -$328 loss by CAR. If NYG wins (on $328 to win $80), Gyno would be down -$-278 instead.
Even if it's PHI visiting ARI for the NFC Championship (best case scenario for Gyno), PHI/ARI would prolly be at pick' em, PHI +100/ARI -105 something like that.
+2400; risk $30 to win $720 for ARI to win NFC Championship
-410; risked $328 to win $80 on CAR; lost
+100 on PHI visiting ARI (fictional numbers for simplicity's sake)... at least risking $358 at +100 would be required.... because if PHI beats ARI, Gyno would want to at least break even (-$30 original bet; -$328 on CAR). But if ARI *do* beat PHI, then we go back to whether this was all worth it (winning the $720 but losing -$328 then something like -$358 on PHI) for a profit of something like $34 on ARI.
I understand both camps' views in this one, really.
* CalvinTy