Would you drop Kenton Keith for Kolby Smith?

Vallon · Nov 7, 2007

I also have Addai, McGahee, Jamal Lewis.

Addict101 · Nov 7, 2007

Hell no.

5starbomb · Nov 7, 2007

Ya I would drop Keith for Kolby... i think its clear addai will get 90% of the carries

Addict101 · Nov 7, 2007

5 star bomb said:
Ya I would drop Keith for Kolby... i think its clear addai will get 90% of the carries

We know nothing of Kolby Smith yet, but we know Keith can get the job done if Addai were to get re-injured. If LJ has struggled all year long behind the KC line, what makes you think an old Priest or a rookie will get it done?

Vallon · Nov 7, 2007

Addict101 said:
We know nothing of Kolby Smith yet, but we know Keith can get the job done if Addai were to get re-injured. If LJ has struggled all year long behind the KC line, what makes you think an old Priest or a rookie will get it done?

true, I really don't want to gamble when there's no real upside in Kolby. Thanks all for the advice.

JakeT. · Nov 7, 2007

I like Keith more.

buddha00man · Nov 9, 2007

keep keith to back up addai but i can see kc going w/ the rookie full time

OJMexico · Nov 14, 2007

As a KC fan I can tell you to stay the hell away from Smith. He's a bruiser but no real speed or agility. Keep Keith, at least Indy spends time in the Red Zone.

5starbomb · Nov 25, 2007

I hope you decided to pick up Kolby Smith like I did!!.... He is breaking out today...

Addict101 · Nov 25, 2007

lol well now the question is totally different. He's all the Chiefs have at this point, and now it appears the season is lost.

5starbomb · Nov 25, 2007

Addict101 said:
lol well now the question is totally different. He's all the Chiefs have at this point, and now it appears the season is lost.

Yeah but who honestly felt Priest could handle a full workload the rest of the season? I know I sure as hell didnt think so. You cant not play for 2 seasons and step right in and take 90% of the carries... Addai is a stud and Keith wont be getting many touches, Kolby was the better pickup in my eyes at the time and looks like I was right!! What a pickup!!

:dancefool