Who will be ranked higher by the playoff committee, Oregon or Alabama ?

[HarryCaray]

This committee must have some real idiots on it.

Please, they know what they're doing; creating drama.

Best way to keep people talking about it is to keep shaking it up, and it is of no consequence because they know it will play itself out on the field.

 

[RunLeeRun]

Well, this ain't your daddy's top 25 ranking.

 

[JakeT.]

AZ has been ranked for several weeks...What do you mean by unranked ? Oregon's victories over Mich St & UCLA are better wins then a win over ND...Committee obviously agrees

When Oregon beat them they were unranked is what I meant.

 

[RunLeeRun]

Please, they know what they're doing; creating drama.

Best way to keep people talking about it is to keep shaking it up, and it is of no consequence because they know it will play itself out on the field.

I think they'll end up causing more problems for themselves by doing a poll every week. They're still figuring this out.

 

[JakeT.]

It appears the main reason Oregon is ranked so high is because they beat a super overrated UCLA squad who the pollsters also have ranked comically too high. That helps the Ducks a ton. UCLA is not a top 5 PAC 12 team IMO.

 

[RunLeeRun]

When Oregon beat them they were unranked.

Do those rankings matter anymore

 

[REDEYE]

It appears the main reason Oregon is ranked so high is because they beat a super overrated UCLA squad who the pollsters also have ranked comically too high. That helps the Ducks a ton. UCLA is not a top 5 PAC 12 team IMO.

these are just you're opinions.... UCLA for whatever you think is still ranked 11th, higher then Notre Dame, and would be favored over ND.....I'm not necessarily saying Oregon should be ranked ov Fla St, but please don't bs us all here that Fla St has better wins, because they don't

 

[akphidelt]

these are just you're opinions.... UCLA for whatever you think is still ranked 11th, higher then Notre Dame, and would be favored over ND.....I'm not necessarily saying Oregon should be ranked ov Fla St, but please don't bs us all here that Fla St has better wins, because they don't

They are undefeated. If we are just going based on wins and not losses, the top 4 SEC West teams should be in the playoffs.

 

[JakeT.]

these are just you're opinions.... UCLA for whatever you think is still ranked 11th, higher then Notre Dame, and would be favored over ND.....I'm not necessarily saying Oregon should be ranked ov Fla St, but please don't bs us all here that Fla St has better wins, because they don't

I just think the Pac 12 is overrated for the millionth year in a row. UCLA could barely get by a shitty Texas squad with half the team suspended. USC lost to shitty Boston College. Stanford couldn't hang with Notre Dame. Arizona, the team that beat Oregon, got all they could handle from powerhouses like UTSA and Nevada. Oregon and Arizona State are the only legit teams from that conference but the pollsters suck off the Pac 12 like they are the SEC. Don't get it.

 

[BAGIANT]

Vegas says Bama would be favored over all these teams!

 

[REDEYE]

I just think the Pac 12 is overrated for the millionth year in a row. UCLA could barely get by a shitty Texas squad with half the team suspended. USC lost to shitty Boston College. Stanford couldn't hang with Notre Dame. Arizona, the team that beat Oregon, got all they could handle from powerhouses like UTSA and Nevada. Oregon and Arizona State are the only legit teams from that conference but the pollsters suck off the Pac 12 like they are the SEC. Don't get it.

You're going to argue against Pac 12 like you have for years....

 

[akphidelt]

The SEC West is the most dominant group of teams in the history of NCAAF. From top to bottom. They are 26-0 outside the SEC, they have one loss outside the SEC West and that was Arkansas losing to Georgia. I think Arkansas would be the 2nd-3rd best team in the PAC-12 and probably the best team in the Big-10!

 

[REDEYE]

The SEC West is the most dominant group of teams in the history of NCAAF. From top to bottom. They are 26-0 outside the SEC, they have one loss outside the SEC West and that was Arkansas losing to Georgia. I think Arkansas would be the 2nd-3rd best team in the PAC-12 and probably the best team in the Big-10!

its nice that you're not on the committee

 

[akphidelt]

its nice that you're not on the committee

I probably know far more about college football than any of the committee members. Anyone who understands football will agree with me. You have to be a very very big homer to think the PAC-12 is even close to the level of talent than the SEC West this year.

 

[JakeT.]

You're going to argue against Pac 12 like you have for years....

Nothing personal. It's just overrated most years. Blame the voters. I'm just the voice of reason.

You guys have an Arizona team close to the top 10 in the nation that could barely beat a 2-7 UTSA team and Nevada of the MAC. Same Nevada team that lost 2 of it's first 3 MAC games. I just think people believe the conference is much better than it really is. The SEC is heads and tails better than everyone this year with the Pac 12, Big 12, and Big Ten grouped a step below, but yet the Pac 12 gets regarded as a top conference and the others don't.

Like I said, blame the voters.

 

[RunLeeRun]

I probably know far more about college football than any of the committee members. Anyone who understands football will agree with me. You have to be a very very big homer to think the PAC-12 is even close to the level of talent than the SEC West this year.

You dont even know a tenth of the football that Tryone Willingham knows, let alone Barry fucking Alvarez, let a-fucking-lone as much as a fermented turd from Tom Osborne's puckered ass. Just when I think you cant possibly be any more ignorant, you reset the bar.

 

[REDEYE]

I probably know far more about college football than any of the committee members. Anyone who understands football will agree with me. You have to be a very very big homer to think the PAC-12 is even close to the level of talent than the SEC West this year.

Don't think anyone on this forum believes you know more then the committee.... You keep beating you're chest with the SEC.. maybe you should pay a little more attention to the argument content.... The current argument is Oregon's quality wins compared to Fla St's...Oregon's are better , especially if you just look at the rankings.. You're next response should have nothing to do with the SEC.. trying to help you here

 

[REDEYE]

Nothing personal. It's just overrated most years. Blame the voters. I'm just the voice of reason.

You guys have an Arizona team close to the top 10 in the nation that could barely beat a 2-7 UTSA team and Nevada of the MAC. Same Nevada team that lost 2 of it's first 3 MAC games. I just think people believe the conference is much better than it really is. The SEC is heads and tails better than everyone this year with the Pac 12, Big 12, and Big Ten grouped a step below, but yet the Pac 12 gets regarded as a top conference and the others don't.

Like I said, blame the voters.

when I think of you as a poster, "voice of reason " isn't something that enters my mind

 

[akphidelt]

You dont even know a tenth of the football that Tryone Willingham knows, let alone Barry fucking Alvarez, let a-fucking-lone as much as a fermented turd from Tom Osborne's puckered ass. Just when I think you cant possibly be any more ignorant, you reset the bar.

False, know plenty more. Not even close.

 

[akphidelt]

Don't think anyone on this forum believes you know more then the committee.... You keep beating you're chest with the SEC.. maybe you should pay a little more attention to the argument content.... The current argument is Oregon's quality wins compared to Fla St's...Oregon's are better , especially if you just look at the rankings.. You're next response should have nothing to do with the SEC.. trying to help you here

Oregon lost.