Who is the most OVERRATED quarterback of all time?

[Acebb]

I find the whole "Elway had to bring his team back, therefore he stunk in the game!!!" line bizarre. Elway wasn't playing defense. And, I've never, ever heard any NFL analyst mock game winning drives.

What a silly thing to say.

 

[Acebb]

Anyway, back to captain over-rated, Aaron Rodgers.

Loses at home as a double-digit favorite against one of the worst teams in the NFL. The Packers ran more than 80 offensive plays in that game and scored 16 points. He was booed and if he were knocked out of the game today he wouldn't be in the HOF. As a comparison, if Ben Roethlisberger never played another snap, he's going to the Hall of Fame.

 

[phdinsports]

I find the whole "Elway had to bring his team back, therefore he stunk in the game!!!" line bizarre. Elway wasn't playing defense. And, I've never, ever heard any NFL analyst mock game winning drives.

What a silly thing to say.

'Cause analysts are always right? Don't throw picks during the game and you won't have to comeback it's that simple! Griese and Plummer had career years playing on that stacked offence without Terrell Davis!! Imagine if they had a healthy Terrell Davis!

 

[tidenation]

Does Jay Cutler ring a bell to anyone? Completely overrated. Sometimes when he is just sitting on the sideline with the same facial expression after throwing a pick i just wanna come through my tv and slap the diabetes outta his ass...

 

[festeringZit]

Manning overated is nonsense. So going 12-4 or 13-3 is just because he plays in the AFC South. Besides the Texans, the Jags and Titans have been good at times during his tenure in Indy. He has the most wins all time as a qb but it only because he played in the AFC South. He also played 4 years in the AFC East. 2nd year went 13-3 in the East.

This is comical. All time leader in wins, all time passer, all time TD's but since he only won 1 SB he stinks. And he had perfect quarterback rating in the PLAYOFFS before. Has won what 4 or 5 MVP's. Could have had perfect season if Dungy wasn't a pussy. Never played with an above average defense.

Nonsense?

Peyton is the choke king. They guy is great, except for when it counts. He holds the record for the most playoff losses ever. And, it's not because he's
won a lot of playoff games to go with it. His all-time playoff record is 11-13 .458.

He's a joke. He's totally over-rated.

 

[Mr_Mark]

Nonsense?

Peyton is the choke king. They guy is great, except for when it counts. He holds the record for the most playoff losses ever. And, it's not because he's
won a lot of playoff games to go with it. His all-time playoff record is 11-13 .458.

He's a joke. He's totally over-rated.

You are looking at 1 aspect. No one has ever claimed for him to be ultimate clutch. Its like saying Farve is a joke because he is the all time interception thrower. Peyt is better than 95% of QBs that ever played.

 

[Vlad the Impaler]

Nonsense?

Peyton is the choke king. They guy is great, except for when it counts. He holds the record for the most playoff losses ever. And, it's not because he's
won a lot of playoff games to go with it. His all-time playoff record is 11-13 .458.

He's a joke. He's totally over-rated.

And how many of those playoff losses came against the team that eventually won it?

 

[festeringZit]

You are looking at 1 aspect. No one has ever claimed for him to be ultimate clutch. Its like saying Farve is a joke because he is the all time interception thrower. Peyt is better than 95% of QBs that ever played.

Just bustin' Vlad's balls a bit.

 

[Mr_Mark]

Just bustin' Vlad's balls a bit.

well carry on then good sir :toast:

 

[Samhain]

Tony Romo

+1

 

[JustinCruise]

+1

How is a guy who went undrafted overrated?

 

[festeringZit]

How is a guy who went undrafted overrated?

Where someone went in the draft has absolutely nothing to do with whether or not they are overrated.

 

[RenoChazz]

Romo's the biggest choke job, not the most overrated. He has really good stats but chokes in big games when everyone is watching.

 

[honzie]

Terry Bradshaw. Along for the ride for all of those Superbowls. I promise you if Dilfer, Hostetler, Williams, et al played on that team they would also have a few rings.

 

[ParlaysStoleMyMoney]

Romo's the biggest choke job, not the most overrated. He has really good stats but chokes in big games when everyone is watching.

You sure about that?

 

[Samhain]

How is a guy who went undrafted overrated?

Romo who has what two playoff wins is considered elite by the sports media yet Eli Manning who has multiple playoff wins, two Super Bowl wins, and two Super Bowl MVP's is not considered elite or in Romo's realm?!?!
Romo if on another team outside of Dallas would be considered a below average QB.