good choices:
Simms very average
Rivers epic choker
Farve turnover machine
Kap complete mystery man
Namath and Bradshaw were before my time but I know this. Only thing you ever hear about Namath is some "guarantee" and all you hear about Bradshaw is 4 Super Bowl rings. I hear people say put Archie Manning on the Steelers and Bradshaw on the Saints, that no one would ever know the name Terry Bradshaw. People used to talk about Tom Brady as "such and such # of rings" but then he started playing off the charts and its not mentioned too much now because he can singlhandedly win games when early in his career that wasn't the case.
Matthew Stafford is up there as far as current qb's. Has the most physically gifted receiver since Moss. Has put up numbers but somwhow never result in wins. Im not talking super bowl wins but just general wins. Coming out of high school, it was basically a given he would be a future #1 pick according to scouts.
I tell you I am always skeptical when someone's greatest strength is their arm strength. That means they are completely trained in their own mind to always rely on that no matter what. Same goes with the whole "mobile" qb. I loved to hear when Vick was in his prime " you just have to teach him to be a pocket passer"....Ok, same goes for almost every qb in the world.
I tell you I am always skeptical when someone's greatest strength is their arm strength. That means they are completely trained in their own mind to always rely on that no matter what. Same goes with the whole "mobile" qb. I loved to hear when Vick was in his prime " you just have to teach him to be a pocket passer"....Ok, same goes for almost every qb in the world.
This was an easy question and I agree 100%. Most over rated QB ever and I have said the same things in the past. If you are great you dont have to come back in the game. Only won the super bowl when he only had to hand the ball off. I think use to think Joe Montana was the greatest of all time but looking at the numbers....Steve Young has great stats. Brady by the end of his career may end up with the best numbers.
The real question is where does Peyton end up? Great numbers regular season but in the big games...betting against him has been $$$.
Take that back. In his prime, the Patriots had his number but who else was exactly beating them then? He misses the season they go 2-14 yet when he was there they were good for at least 12 wins every year. And not to mention, he kinda has set a few records. Calling Manning overated is nuts even a common sense Patriot fan would admit that...I don't rip on you like others but that is crazy.
Manning overated is nonsense. So going 12-4 or 13-3 is just because he plays in the AFC South. Besides the Texans, the Jags and Titans have been good at times during his tenure in Indy. He has the most wins all time as a qb but it only because he played in the AFC South. He also played 4 years in the AFC East. 2nd year went 13-3 in the East.
This is comical. All time leader in wins, all time passer, all time TD's but since he only won 1 SB he stinks. And he had perfect quarterback rating in the PLAYOFFS before. Has won what 4 or 5 MVP's. Could have had perfect season if Dungy wasn't a pussy. Never played with an above average defense.
