This 8-team playoff non-sense is the dumbest thing. All that is going to do is incentivize teams to schedule absolutely nobody OOC to avoid loses and have a chance to get into the playoff. What year has there ever been 8 deserving teams? Hell, what year has there ever been 5? I'd argue that a 3-team playoff with the #1 team getting a bye would be more appropriate. Anytime there has been a debate with the BCS, it basically was a 2 teams debating for the 2nd spot in the NC game….and this year is no exception.
In the BCS era, I can think of only 4 years where there was a debate beyond the top-2 teams:
2011 (Bama vs OkSt)
2008 (Ok vs Texas)
2004 (Auburn)
2003 (LSU vs USC)
Other than the above 4 years, there has clearly been 2 teams better than everyone else. Ohio St, TCU, and Baylor are good teams but its pretty clear that Oregon, FSU, and Alabama are the best 3 teams this year. Going to 8-teams will just water it down and there will be some really bad teams that backdoor their way into it by playing weak schedules.