Total Quarterback Rating

[GunShark]

This is something I saw on ESPN.
This is a better system than the old passer rating because QBR adds the real life game factors to the QB.
A scale from 0 to 100. 100 being the best, 0 being the worst.

Top 10 Quarterbacks based on this new rating.

1. Tom Brady 76.0
2. Peyton Manning 69.5
3. Matt Ryan 68.6
4. Aaron Rodgers 67.9
5. Michael Vick 66.6
6. Drew Brees 65.9
7. Eli Manning 64.3
8. Josh Freeman 63.5
9. Phillip Rivers 63.2
10. Ben Roethlisberger 59.8

Michael Vick had a perfect game @ the Redskins in the 2010 season. 99.8 QBR rating.

 

[Hamilbet]

I like the idea of the new system. It does give a better overall rating to the QB position. At the same time keeping simple on the 0-100 scale. What I don't like is how the rating is rated. The system is subjective to who is doing the rating. I saw a half hour special on ESPN about how they determine the rating. There is definite opinion involved. I am curious to see how it pans out over the first couple of weeks. But overall I do think it is a good new stat catagory.

 

[TheCommish]

It will replace the older system. It is better since the old system has been around since 1973 and the game has changed a ton since then.