Bengals @ Saints
Drew Brees’ mother passed away suddenly last Friday in Colorado. Monday he was back in camp, for better or worse. Grieving while preparing for the first preseason game of the year may make it hard to focus all the time, but Drew is as mentally tough as any QB out there. He’ll probably get 1 series in this game, leaving backups Brunnel and Harrington to battle for the backup role. How much the unfortunate death affects the intensity of the team heading into this game – well, it’s impossible for me to know, but I’m deducting a point from the spread from the Saints for the distraction/grieving/sympathies involved. Life is bigger than football.
With Brunnel and Harrington playing the majority of the game, the Saints will always have a quarterback in the game with good NFL experience and the ability to manage a game. Indeed, no other team has as much combined experience at the 2nd and 3rd string QB position as the Saints. They proved last year after numerous injuries to their WR and TE corps that they have pretty good depth at those positions as well. The Saints vertical attack should get a bit more horizontal once Brees leaves the game, which won’t be far into this contest. And so we reach the end of the positive things you can say about the Saints.
Their run game and defense were sub-par last year, and probably won’t be much improved this year, good intentions aside. They’ve got a new DC with Gregg Williams, but just don’t look to have the bodies or depth to take advantage of the wide assortment of defensive looks he wants to implement this year. So while the Saints will be creating a lot of confusion with their defensive formations and schemes, how much of that confusion they can shift onto their offensive opponent’s remains to be seen. The Saints were torched by big plays repeatedly last year, and should suffer a similar fate, at least early in the season.
The Bengals, in spite of suffering through a miserable 2008 campaign, have kept their coaching staff intact. Obviously, injuries on both sides of the ball shot their season down early, none so costly as losing QB Carson Palmer a few games in. Starting fresh with a mostly healthy roster (their tight ends are in bad shape right now after losing Reggie Kelly for the year and Ben Utecht getting his bell rung in a bad way), the Bengals are poised to surprise with some good covers early in the season. Well, no game is earlier than preseason week #1, and I have them covering here. Granted, things get pretty hair at QB after Carson leaves the game (he’ll play a minimum 2 series, I believe). It’s up to J.T. O’Turnover Sullivan and “Yes, I’m actually his brother” Jordan Palmer to not fudge things up too badly for the rest of the team. It will be a fun matchup to see how the Saints new defensive aggression fairs versus the extremely unpredictable O’Sullivan. There’s going to be a big play most times he drops back to pass, for one team or the other. Jordan Palmer at least has the advantage of having spent a season with the team, so he may surprise with a few well-executed plays.
Teams built on offensive finesse and timing, like the Saints, Colts (under Dungy), Cards and Eagles, all have losing preseason records with their current or most recent coaches. These teams defenses tend to mirror their offenses, being built on speed and pass defense well suited to protect the lead their potent offenses have gotten them.
Smash-mouth, physical running teams tend to fair better in the preseason, as this style of ball fairs better deeper into the roster with a perhaps more simplified run-centric playbook that is easier to execute. Teams that have traditionally favored the run, the Jaguars, Panthers and Bucs fit this description, and all have excellent preseason records under their current or most recent coaches. Now, how much of this preseason spunk is down to the coaches desire to win or the schemes built on their finesse or physical styles is open to some debate, I reckon, but scanning over the records of preseason coaches my reasoning stands up pretty well. Mike Shanahan had a stellar preseason record, and though the Broncos have traditionally been a more finesse than physical team, they’ve almost always had an excellent run game. Belichick has a winning preseason record as well, but Bill is Bill, the best coach in the league, and he’s been able to compliment Brady’s terrific passing attack with a good run game and a physical defense for the most part.
To be fair, Sean Payton’s preseason record isn’t far on the losing side at 6-7, and Marvin Lewis’ preseason record for the Bengals is 12-12. But that really kind of sums it up – the Bengals are a little bit more physical and this game that will see very little of Drew Brees is really up for grabs, meaning there’s great value on the Bengals getting 3 points.
Final Score Prediction: Bengals 20 – Saints 17