Should I...?

[roundrobin11]

...make this trade?

12 team league, start 2qb, 2rb, 3wr, 1te, 1k, 1d/st

my team

qb- cutler, schaub, clausen
rb- ray rice, cadillac, portis, jerome harrison (i had ryan grant)
wr- garcon, walter, clayton (stl), mike wallace
te- finley, miller

i am in desperate need of WR help. i have the best qbs in the league, 2 #1 guys

this is the deal...

ray rice and kevin walter for knowshon moreno and desean jackson

im very reluctant to deal rice, but this could make my WRs alot better (it would give me legit #1,2,3 wrs) and i would still have pretty good RBs

what you all think? should i keep my wrs as is and hope wallace can produce when big ben comes back adn keep working the waiver wire or should i make this deal?

thanks guys

 

[bscloud]

what is the scoring format? if you're playing PPR i would be hesitant to deal rice simply because he will catch 70+ balls out of the backfield this year. having said that, getting jackson and moreno in return is a good deal. even if andre johnson goes down walter will be a wr2 at best. i am not very high on rice this year anyhow as the ravens have too many weapons on offense and a jerk called willis who steals goal line carries. if i were in your shoes i would do this trade. either that or try and offer cutler/schaub instead of rice. my 2 cents.

 

[JakeT.]

Jackson is not going to be the same WR with Vick starting. I'm not sure if I do the trade or not but that is worth noting.

 

[JakeT.]

Moreno is probably a top 12 RB but I'm still not sure I'd do it. Garcon and Wallace should be good this season. Maybe try the WW instead of giving up your best RB? It would be different if I had Jackson as a top 20 fantasy WR this year.

 

[roundrobin11]

jake... the guy im looking to deal with also has moss and meachem. would you do it for moss?

bscloud... i know i cant stand willis! but they had him last year and rice still racked up TDs, and it is not a PPR league