FWIW, That would hold weight if his past GOY 5* were horrible as well. But 27-7 L34 years says a lot. He has had bad 5* GOM prior to his GOY and still done well on the GOY and Bowl and well as Pro GOY those 3 he's consistently good on as well as his 4.5* Total of the year.
With that said, todays mass murdering of Army as N. Dmae 5* -13.5 easily wins 44-6. Did I mention his Top 3.5* total of the week Ov 71 NAVY cruises easily as well. Im the first to admit he blows early on. I hate listening to his comp tapes and he always finds something big to talk about. The smirking of the dude on phone when Phil is doing something good makes me sick when off a bad week or Big game loss prior weekend. Nonetheless, he delivered today with his 5* and his whole card is killing it. So prepare tomorrow AM to hear how great he is. MF'r need to be humble IMO, but humble doesn't sell packages.