Peyton Manning for Steve Slaton?

[Banker]

Would anyone here consider trading Peyton Manning for Steve Slaton in a 14 team league. I feel that Peyton is gonna struggle this year with a depleted receiving core and new coach. Slaton has sucked for the first 2 weeks, but if he lives up to his potential, watch out. Am I thinking about this right? Fair or completely lopsided?

Thanks for the opinions.

 

[gelo24]

I really like Steve Slaton because his production in the first two weeks has coincided with two very difficult matchups vs. the Jets and Titans. The problem with this deal is in a 14-team league it is going to be difficult to replace Manning. I would want to know who your backup QB is or what QBs are available on the waiver wire. Good luck with whatever you decide.

 

[FairWarning]

I really like Steve Slaton because his production in the first two weeks has coincided with two very difficult matchups vs. the Jets and Titans. The problem with this deal is in a 14-team league it is going to be difficult to replace Manning. I would want to know who your backup QB is or what QBs are available on the waiver wire. Good luck with whatever you decide.

Agree. For this to work, they probably have to make a two for two trade. Can't imagine anyone on WW.