Need advice for semi-final playoffs week 15!!

[MakeitRainon'em]

QB: *P. Manning or Aaron Rodgers
WR(pick 2): *Calvin Johnson, *Isaac Bruce, Kevin
Walter, Antwaan Randle El
RB (pick 2): *Marshawn Lynch, *Maurice Morris, Tim
Hightower (May pick up Cadillac Williams
off waivers)
TE: *Dallas Clark or Owen Daniels
K: *Neil Rackers
DEF: *New York Giants

*Denotes current starters (Matt Forte and Marques Colston already played)

Should I pick up another DEF? I don't know if I can trust the Giants against Dallas.

Thanks in advance!!!

 

[FairWarning]

Manning barely over Rodgers
Walter/Bruce (Colts are 1st vs WRs this year, hurts CJ)
Lynch/Morris
Clark (both are great matchups)

Whats your other D choices? Giants are very highly rated. Maybe pick up one now for next week, hoping you win.

 

[JakeT.]

I think you have the right choices. FairWarning brings up a good point on the Colts' defense but I'd leave CJ in there with the Lions likely having to pass the entire 2nd half to stay involved.

 

[theDude24]

Agree - I would leave CJ in over Bruce!!!!

Also - i hate Maurice Morris - any other options on waivers (Dominic Rhodes maybe?)

Also agree on Peyton over Rodgers (again, barely)