Dave Cokin
Monday Bonus Play 7:05 PM
MLB (911) NEW YORK YANKEES (912) TORONTO BLUE JAYS
Take: (912) TORONTO BLUE JAYS -112
If you’ve followed my analysis over the years, you already know I’m fond of playing on rookie pitchers in their first journeys around the loop. Two key reasons stand out here. One is the hitters being unfamiliar with these guys, and initially at least, that’s frequently an advantage for the pitchers. Secondly, the betting lines can often be favorable to these unknown commodities. Maybe not so much if it’s a big name rookie, but when it’s a secondary guy, I think there’s value to be had backing them.
The second time around is often not so kind to the first year hurlers. Now the hitters have a book and it’s here when we start to find out if the rookie sensations have any staying power. That brings me to Chase Whitley, who will throw for the Yankees tonight as they open a series in Toronto with the Blue Jays.
Whitley has been more than a pleasant surprise for the Yankees. He is not a high end prospect, and had basically been an anonymous relief pitcher in the organization till this spring. Not anymore! Whitley has raised lots of eyebrows in his maiden big league voyage, and for the time being at least, he’s establishing himself as a fixture in this year’s Yanks rotation. Whitley has been handled very well, as manager Joe Girardi has kept him on a short leash. But there can’t be any question that Whitley has been an unexpected asset for a team that in spite of some obvious shortcomings, is very much in the AL playoff chase.
Tonight could be a different story for Whitley. The Blue Jays are facing him for the second time in succession and I’m not going to be surprised if they knock the kid around some this evening. Those veteran Jays hitters are going to adjust off what they just saw. Countering doesn’t figure to be easy for the still raw rookie.
Marcus Stroman is another rookie, albeit the Blue Jays kid has a much more public pedigree than Whitley and he looks to have a pretty high ceiling as well. Stroman struggled in his first test with the Yankees, as he had trouble with his command throughout what turned out to be a rather short stint. Prior to that poor performance, Stroman had looked very good in three straight starts, in spite of being unlucky with a bloated BABIP.
As for the rest, the Yankees are off two pretty ugly offensive games against the Orioles, and it wasn’t like those came against Adam Wainwright and Andrew Cashner (you knew I’d find a way to slip that in here someplace, right?). The Blue Jays will likely be minus Jose Bautista tonight from what I can gather and I’d check the status of Adam Lind before getting involved. But I believe this number is a little on the short side and I’m leaning toward the idea of teams catching up to Whitley the second time around. I’ll go Blue Jays as the comp play tonight.