I was offered this trade.....

[5starbomb]

Here is the trade, I wont tell you which part of it is my team just tell me what side you thinking is getting the better deal. I will tell you what part of the trade is my team after I get some feedback. The league is 1 point per reception league and 6pts for all tds



P. Manning
L. Evans
B. Edwards
E. Johnson (Saints)

for

Mcnabb
S. Smith (panthers)
Curry
gates

 

[secksiaccord]

i'd take the team with smith n gates hands down.

 

[Addict101]

Unless passing TDs are worth 6 points in your league, I'd take the side with Smith. Manning is obviously better than McNabb, but the rest is totally uneven with Smith over Evans, Curry over Edwards, and the biggest being Gates over Johnson.

 

[5starbomb]

Addict passing tds are 6 points. All tds in our league are 6 pts. Do you think that makes getting Manning worth it? I am the team with Smith and Gates. I dont want to get rid of Gates but getting Manning and 2 good wrs might be worth it. I think Lee Evans is going to turn it around and Edwards has been real good so far this season.... I would disagree with you that Curry is better than Edwards also but thats my opinion

 

[Addict101]

Addict passing tds are 6 points. All tds in our league are 6 pts. Do you think that makes getting Manning worth it? I am the team with Smith and Gates. I dont want to get rid of Gates but getting Manning and 2 good wrs might be worth it. I think Lee Evans is going to turn it around and Edwards has been real good so far this season.... I would disagree with you that Curry is better than Edwards also but thats my opinion

Manning is a stud in 6 pt passing td leagues. That's tough. I'm starting to think that Smith is going to be a bust just because Carr doesn't know how to throw the deep ball at an NFL level. Delhomme might need surgery, so trading Smith might not be a bad idea. Curry and Edwards a wash then we'll call it, but the Johnson for Gates thing is just so lopsided. That's a really tough call dude. Remember that Marvin is hurt right now for Indy.

 

[5starbomb]

Manning is a stud in 6 pt passing td leagues. That's tough. I'm starting to think that Smith is going to be a bust just because Carr doesn't know how to throw the deep ball at an NFL level. Delhomme might need surgery, so trading Smith might not be a bad idea. Curry and Edwards a wash then we'll call it, but the Johnson for Gates thing is just so lopsided. That's a really tough call dude. Remember that Marvin is hurt right now for Indy.

Yeah I am thinking the same thing with Steve Smith. With Carr in there I think Smiths #'s are going to take a big hit and honestly even Mcnabb has some question marks with me right now. He cant move around as good as he once did and his O line and wrs arnt getting the job done either. If Westbrook has problems staying healthy it could mean only more trouble for Mcnabb who besides vs the Lions hasnt done too much so far. I know the Gates/Johnson part is a HUGE difference but I am contemplating whether upgrading at WR and at QB are worth it. I think Evans and Edwards are both solid #2 wr's for 12 team fantasy leagues..... Man this is a fuckin tough decision

 

[JakeT.]

I'd take the side with Manning personally. Eric Johnson IMO is in the tier of TEs right below Gates and Steve Smith and the Panthers have some issues at QB and O line.

 

[gynecologist]

I'd take the Manning team as well.

 

[5starbomb]

TRADE ACCEPTED!! I decided to pull the trigger guys. Thanks for all the input, I had to do the trade after I saw the fantasy master Gyno approve of it. You ever going to lose dude? lol, anyway the reason I decided to do it is I have my question marks right now with Mcnabb and Smith with the way the Panthers and Eagles O line and Carr in Carolina. I think Evans is going to bounce back nicely and Edwards has been playing good. It will suck not having Gates but oh well... Thanks guys

 

[brian4state]

Was late getting in on thread, but looks like a great deal for you.