Dumsfeld Ignored Pentagon Advise

Search
Sat Mar 29, 6:39 PM ET

WASHINGTON (Reuters) - Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld repeatedly rejected advice from Pentagon (news - web sites) planners that substantially more troops and armor would be needed to fight a war in Iraq (news - web sites), New Yorker Magazine reported.


In an article for its April 7 edition, which goes on sale on Monday, the weekly said Rumsfeld insisted at least six times in the run-up to the conflict that the proposed number of ground troops be sharply reduced and got his way.


"He thought he knew better. He was the decision-maker at every turn," the article quoted an unidentified senior Pentagon planner as saying. "This is the mess Rummy put himself in because he didn't want a heavy footprint on the ground."


It also said Rumsfeld had overruled advice from war commander Gen. Tommy Franks to delay the invasion until troops denied access through Turkey could be brought in by another route and miscalculated the level of Iraqi resistance.


"They've got no resources. He was so focused on proving his point -- that the Iraqis were going to fall apart," the article, by veteran journalist Seymour Hersh, cited an unnamed former high-level intelligence official as saying.


A spokesman at the Pentagon declined to comment on the article.


Rumsfeld is known to have a difficult relationship with the Army's upper echelons while he commands strong loyalty from U.S. special operations forces, a key component in the war.


He has insisted the invasion has made good progress since it was launched 10 days ago, with some ground troops 50 miles from the capital, despite unexpected guerrilla-style attacks on long supply lines from Kuwait.


Hersh, however, quoted the former intelligence official as saying the war was now a stalemate.


Much of the supply of Tomahawk cruise missiles has been expended, aircraft carriers were going to run out of precision guided bombs and there were serious maintenance problems with tanks, armored vehicles and other equipment, the article said.


"The only hope is that they can hold out until reinforcements arrive," the former official said.


The article quoted the senior planner as saying Rumsfeld had wanted to "do the war on the cheap" and believed that precision bombing would bring victory.
 

RX Senior
Joined
Sep 20, 2000
Messages
8,135
Tokens
Rumsfeld ought to be fired. He has caused severe problems militarily and politically.
 
i tend to agree with mr smith....but,i hate seeing one guy "scapegoated" when things don`t go as planned.....as much as i am behind our country,i have serious concerns regarding our preparation for this monumental undertaking......rumsfeld may be a large part of the problem.....but,i think,if things go south,there will plenty of blame to go around...i hope they aren`t setting up one guy as a sacrificial lamb in case things go badly.....it`s still very early.......but,it seems certain things may have been overlooked in preparation for this undertaking....and that`s tragedy....for all concerned....
 

New member
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
883
Tokens
What the hell did you expect, none of these guys have any millitary service.
 

New member
Joined
Sep 20, 2000
Messages
15,635
Tokens
I back up the effort and the goal and the reason 100%, but they should have waited till the fall before the invasion.They should have had no one in the theater until late spring when Saddams ignoring of inspection could have been more highlighted.And all the horseshit excuses by the UN would have been proven.
 
There must be a severe rift between the Pentagon and Rumsfeld for these type stories to start leaking.


Passing the buck after one week?
 

Member
Handicapper
Joined
Jan 20, 2002
Messages
6,932
Tokens
I don't know what war you guys are watching.

This war couldn't be going better. Rumsfeld and Franks are kicking ass with this PC war that we are fighting.
 

New member
Joined
Sep 20, 2004
Messages
1,267
Tokens
The US military is taking care of business. All you guys dogging Rumsfeld have no military experience either. It couldn't go any better than this.
 
gambling....looks like you were right on.....a great tactical plan......some of us(myself included) allowed the agenda-driven media to influence their perception of what was actually happening.....i`ve never been more grateful to have been wrong.....
 

Forum statistics

Threads
1,119,159
Messages
13,564,729
Members
100,753
Latest member
aw8vietnam
The RX is the sports betting industry's leading information portal for bonuses, picks, and sportsbook reviews. Find the best deals offered by a sportsbook in your state and browse our free picks section.FacebookTwitterInstagramContact Usforum@therx.com