you could argue Mclouth and Douhmit have been their 2 best hitters this yr.
Duke, Sanchez, Adam LaRoche and Snell have been playing hurt all year.with those 2, Nady, Bay, throw in Jack Wilson who has had some yrs batting over .300 and last yrs batting champ Freddy Sanchez and the Pirates actually had a very solid lineup. "IF" Snell could have pitched as he did last yr, Duke could somehow have regained his form of his rookie yr to go along with Maholm's solid yr, and a healthy Matt Capps closing games the Pirates should have been a .500 ball club this yr.
Duke, Sanchez, Adam LaRoche and Snell have been playing hurt all year.