Day One Recap
March 21, 2014
While on one hand, the talking heads around the country seem to be collectively willing Michigan State and Louisville and any other “public” team to make deep runs in the Big Dance, nothing captivates the masses quite like a Cinderella story in the postseason, or upsets of any kind. Which is why the most-compelling storylines of Thursday’s NCAA sub-regional action involved a near upset of Rick Pitino’s Cardinals and a couple of “non-upset” upsets that had the network commentators and analysts acting as if they had just watched a basketball equivalent of Buster Douglas shocking Mike Tyson by knockout, 24 years ago (can it be that long since that night in Tokyo?).
Indeed, there was nothing too earth-shattering about well-respected 12th seed North Dakota State, which closed a 3 to 3½-point underdog, knocking off 5th seed Oklahoma by an 80-75 count in overtime at Spokane (though the game did feature some last-second dramatics that allowed the Bison to force overtime). Nor was 12th-seeded Harvard’s win, by a 61-57 count over another five seed, Cincinnati, considered much of an upset, given that the Crimson closed as a mere 2½ -point dog. After all, Harvard did the same thing last season, beating New Mexico, only in a more-genuine upset, by almost the same score (61-58), at Salt Lake City.
There were, however, some exciting moments on Thursday, when four of the sixteen now-called “second-round” games required overtime. As has often been the case in recent Big Dances, the five seed was a treacherous one, with aforementioned Oklahoma and Cincinnati going down vs. 12 seeds, while another five, Saint Louis, was all but beaten in its matchup vs. 12-seed NC State at Orlando before rallying from 16 down deep in the second half (more on that game in a moment). Other historical notes on Thursday included aforementioned Harvard becoming the first Ivy entry since Pete Carril’s Princeton of 1983-84 to win games in back-to-back NCAA Tourneys, while those Bison of ND State became the first team from North Dakota to ever win a game in the Dance.
Still, a lot of the noteworthy games on Thursday were caused by some very careless and sloppy play by teams, with some of them noted in our highlights of the day.
1. NC State’s collapse vs. Saint Louis...When the Wolfpack stretch the lead to 16 points (55-39) with eight minutes to play, and still led by 14 with five minutes to go, the Billikens should have been finished. Instead, Mark Gottfried’s team began an excruciating meltdown caused mostly by faulty free throw shooting, missing a staggering 11 charity tosses in the final 3:09 to enable Saint Louis to force an overtime and then prevail, 83-80. The otherwise-marvelous NC State soph, T. J. Warren, scored 28 points, but missed 8 of his 14 free throw tries, and that doesn’t count the one he missed and then stepped over the free-throw stripe too early too negate his a rebound of his own miss. It does include his miss of a possible game-tying FT with 30 seconds to play that would have completed a 3-point play. Instead, he unwisely was the NC State player who committed the foul on the subsequent SLU possession, disqualifying him from proceedings, meaning he was off the court when the Wolfpack had two more possessions and a chance to tie the game.
2. Louisville’s escape...Facing a mirror-image Manhattan side coached by Rick Pitino disciple Steve Masiello, the defending champion Cardinals were in deep trouble and trailed by 3 with inside of four minutes to play before some late triples by Russ Smith and Luke Hancock bailed out the ‘Ville in a 71-64 final that was much closer than the scoreline suggests. Manhattan showed absolutely no fear of the Cardinals and reminded the many ‘Ville cheerleaders in the media that Pitino’s team is far from invincible. As for Masiello, he has instantly become one of the new flavors of the month in the coaching circle, although his Pitino-like approach suggests he has the stuff to be one of the next big-name coaches. Whether current openings such as Boston College, Virginia Tech or Wake Forest are enough to lure him remain to be seen; something tells us Masiello might be waiting for a call from a bigger name in the not-too-distant future.
3. Dayton drama...Thursday promised to be a chaotic day from the outset when the very first tip-off of the day between Dayton and Ohio State ended with a frenzied finish. In a back-and-forth game, the Flyers’ Vee Sanford drove past Ohio State’s Aaron Craft and banked in a go-ahead runner with 3.8 seconds to go, providing the winning points in Dayton’s 60-59 win that wasn’t secured until Craft’s off-balance attempt at the buzzer, after a breathless near full-court dash in the final seconds, bounced off of the rim and backboard. Thad Matta’s Buckeyes thus ended their string of four straight Sweet 16 appearances.
4. Texas drama...Thrill-ride finish number two of the day happened in Milwaukee where the longhorns scored a buzzer-beating 87-85 win over Arizona State. It was not artistic, as the last two key Texas baskets, including a three-point play by Jonathan Holmes with 32 seconds to play, and Cameron Ridley’s short bank shot at the buzzer, were made possible only by horrifically-missed Texas field goal attempts that didn’t even hit the rim, first by Javan Felix and next by Holmes in the final seconds, to move the Longhorns a chance at rebounds they probably don’t get on a regular missed shot. Homes’ three -point misfire in the final seconds was so “short” that it took an unnatural bounce off of the lower portion of the backboard to Ridley, who otherwise was too deep to snare a normal rebound bounce. Holmes had earlier fielded a Felix air ball to score his big bucket. Sometimes, being a bit lucky is better than being a bit good.
5. The twelve seeds strike again...Again, we’re not sure that previously-mentioned wins by Harvard and North Dakota State were really upsets at all. Harvard’s credentials as a legit March entry were established a year ago with a similar lineup. The Bison needed a bit more drama to get past Oklahoma, with Lawrence Alexander’s triple with 12 seconds to play bringing NDSU level with Oklahoma to 66-66 and presaging the overtime period that the Bison dominated. What might impress more about the NDSU win was that top scorer Taylor Braun did not contribute much, missing 8 of 11 field goal tries en route to a subpar 11-point effort...yet the Bison still won and will face San Diego State on Saturday. The remaining fifth seed on Friday, Virginia Commonwealth, is thus forewarned about its matchup with Southland champ Stephen F Austin.
5. Aztecs near meltdown...Speaking of San Diego State, the last 118 times it had led with five minutes to play entering Thursday night’s game at Spokane against New Mexico State, the Aztecs had won. The streak is now at 119 after the 73-69 OT victory over New Mexico State, but the latest win probably merits an asterisk, because it didn’t have to be so close. Steve Fisher’s team led by eight with 1:24 to play before missed free throws, blown box-outs and one disastrous turnover enabled the Aggies to tie the game with a deep 3-pointer with six seconds left in regulation. Xavier Thames scored five points in overtime to help the Aztecs survive.
6. Will a 16 seed ever beat a 1 seed? We’ll have three more longshot chances on Friday, but there might be hope for the 16s after Albany put up a very decent fight vs. South top seed Florida at Orlando, with the Gators forced to work hard before finally settling for a 77-65 win over the 22-point underdog Great Danes, who might have confused Florida with their two-toned shorts that were somewhat reminiscent of Chuck Wepner’s blue-and-red trunks from his 1975 fight vs. Muhammad Ali at the old Richfield Coliseum outside of Cleveland. In Albany’s case, the colors are purple and gold, and its Great Dane mascot was one of Thursday’s best. On Friday, Coastal Carolina (vs. Virginia), Cal Poly SLO (vs. Wichita State), and Weber State (vs. Arizona) give it another shot for the 16s, who have been on an 0-fer ever since they debuted at the 1985 version of the Big Dance.
7. Conference update....We were about to start talking about the revival of the ACC until NC State surrendered that late lead against Saint Louis, as Pitt and Syracuse (loop newcomers both, but now ACC members all the same) had impressed in their wins earlier in the day. Virginia, North Carolina, and Duke get their shots on Friday. If there is a conference to take note of thus far in the college postseason (all tourneys considered), it might be the Summit, whose aforementioned North Dakota State won over Oklahoma, but also netted success in the CIT, where IPFW beat Akron and Nebraska-Omaha whipped North Dakota, with all Summit reps also covering numbers in the process. The only Summit casualty in early action came in the CBI, where South Dakota State lost close at Old Dominion.
We just had to make those CIT and CBI mentions!