. His action didn't prevent Detroit from recovering it, it was going out of bounds anyway. Did he "bat" the ball, 50/50.
The ball isn't round so there was a very good chance it could have bounced backwards or to the right or to the left.
Did he "bat" the ball??? 100% he did.
Its a stupid rule IMO but there is no doubt whatsoever that there should have been a flag thrown. Based on the rule.