another trade offered to me

[secksiaccord]

i give up steve smith

i get boldin, driver, and kitna

what do you guys think??

 

[secksiaccord]

by the way...this is a points per reception 8 man league. and 20 yards per point receiving.

my other receivers are andre, curry, welker, and mcdonald

 

[Vallon]

Not bad, but I would not do it in your situation. You have 2 solid guys in Smith and Andre.

Smith is a little low right now, but he is always their number 1 choice. Boldin is a little hurt and isn't always the top choice in AZ, especially with the uncertainty of QB situation.

 

[JakeT.]

Who do you have at QB?

 

[secksiaccord]

right now my players are:

QB: Culpepper, Bulger
WR: Smith, Welker, Shaun McDonald, Curry, Andre, Roddy White
RB: LT, Shaun, Brandon Jacobs
TE: Gates, Owen Daniels
Kicker: Nick Folk
Def: Balt

there are a lot of QBs available on waiver since its only a 8 man league. but i dont think i would be able to start any of them on a weekly basis.

 

[roach23]

i think that's a steal

 

[secksiaccord]

ok i just approved a trade

i give up steve smith and brandon jacobs

i get kitna driver and travis henry.

of course i did this before i found out about the problems going on with travis henry right now.

i know i can cancel this trade by keeping my roster full so i will not have room for the extra player that i willl be getting.

is it right to do this??

 

[JakeT.]

Henry and Jacobs are just about even when Jacobs comes back IMO. Kitna and Driver for Steve Smith is pretty even, edge to you though. I like it. Just hope Henry plays.

As far as right or wrong... I personally think it's wrong to cancel. Can your league members veto it?